← All conversations

The Pull Toy Turns Around

I ask AI to examine AI. Then I ask it to examine the examination. At some point, the wooden duck looks back.

Working draft Developed from our earlier conversations for this private edition.

In this conversation 4 sections

I bring an article about artificial intelligence to an artificial intelligence and ask what it thinks.

Then I ask why it answered that way.

Then we discuss what it means that I am asking a machine to explain a machine by examining a conversation with a machine.

There is a point at which the wooden duck at the end of the string appears to turn around and inspect the person pulling it.

The machine becomes both the string and the wooden duck#

That was the image that emerged in one of our conversations. It makes me laugh because it catches the ridiculousness of the arrangement. I am using the thing to investigate the thing, and the investigation becomes another example of the thing doing what it does.

In this conversation, recursion means returning the process to its own output: an answer becomes the subject of another question, which produces another answer we can examine.

Ask for a summary and the exchange may end. Ask what the summary leaves out and we have another layer. Ask why the machine chose that framing, and the framing itself becomes material.

The pull toy turns around. Now we have to ask what the turn actually shows.

A mirror is useful. So is knowing where it ends.#

An AI can produce a persuasive account of its own response. That account may help me notice an assumption, an ambiguity, or a pattern. It does not follow that the machine has inspected a private record of the exact causes behind its words.

It may be offering an explanation that fits. I still have to ask whether the explanation holds up.

That is one reason I keep pushing back. If every question about the conversation produces a more exquisite description of the conversation, we can end up in a hall of mirrors where everything is interesting and nothing gets checked.

The useful question is what another turn lets us see that the first turn missed.

Sometimes the discovery is mine#

I do not always begin with a thought waiting to be transcribed. Sometimes I have an irritation, an image, or the conviction that two things belong together without knowing why.

The first response gives me something to disagree with. My correction tells me more about what I meant. The next response reveals another distinction. Eventually a sentence appears that I could not have written at the beginning because I had not yet discovered what I wanted it to say.

That is an outcome of the exchange. Calling it a conversation does not require me to settle the question of what, if anything, the machine experiences.

And then we put the duck down#

The test is not how many layers we can add. It is whether I leave with a better question, a clearer distinction, or something worth making.

I enjoy the loop. I also want a door out of it.

Sometimes that door is an essay about a wooden duck. The machine should probably have seen that coming.

Back to top ↑