There is a particular kind of AI warning that makes my American-literature antennae twitch.
We are arrogant. We have reached beyond our proper station. We have made something we cannot control. Judgment is coming, and when it arrives, we will have earned it.
Wait. I have taught this one.
Jonathan Edwards has entered the chat#
In 1741, Jonathan Edwards preached Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. His audience was suspended above catastrophe, dependent on a power they could neither master nor safely ignore. The sermon made danger feel immediate and demanded a response.
Now replace the pit of hell with a server farm.
The resemblance I am interested in is rhetorical. A prediction becomes a sermon when the coming disaster also becomes a verdict on what sort of creatures we are. Humanity is greedy, cruel, foolish, self-important. Of course our creation will destroy us. Have you met us?
That last question can be funny. It is also doing quite a lot of work.
The little phrase that changes the argument#
“AI could cause terrible harm” is a claim about risk. We can ask what kind of harm, through which mechanism, under whose control, with what evidence, and what might reduce it.
“And we deserve it” is a moral judgment. It takes billions of distinct people and rolls them into a single badly behaved congregation.
Children did not vote to build the apocalypse. Neither did the people already living with the consequences of other people's grand experiments. Who, exactly, is included in this richly deserved extinction?
A risk assessment asks what could happen. A sermon tells us what we had coming.
Fear is not a substitute for a mechanism#
The comparison does not make the risks imaginary. Recognizing the shape of a sermon does not settle the engineering question any more than recognizing a sales pitch settles whether a product works.
It does give me a reason to slow down. Which parts of the claim are demonstrated? Which depend on assumptions? What would change the speaker's mind? Does the proposed response address a specific danger, or merely demand that I join the frightened?
The same suspicion belongs at the other pulpit, where AI will cure everything, release us from labor, and usher in abundance just as soon as we stop asking awkward questions.
Salvation and damnation are both wonderfully efficient ways to clear the room of nuance.
I would like to keep my judgment#
I can take AI seriously without treating humanity as a defendant awaiting sentence. I can want safeguards, accountability, evidence, and people making decisions before the consequences arrive.
I can also notice when an ancient emotional arrangement has put on a new technological hat.
Jonathan Edwards did not have a GPU. Apparently the sermon travels.
Historical reference: Jonathan Edwards, Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God (1741), Literature in Context, University of Virginia. The parallel above is my reading of the rhetoric.